181 | High ticket sales for entrepreneurs who feel icky about selling, with business coach Sara Torpey

Ill Communication Podcast, Episode 181

Let's get one thing straight. Sales is not sleazy.

I know. A lot of us (women especially) were raised to think selling is pushy, greedy and a little bit gross. And if you're a coach, healer, teacher or any kind of helper, it can feel even worse. Like charging for your gift is somehow wrong.

This week on the podcast, I'm switching things up. Earlier this year, my business friend Sara Torpey had me on her podcast, Uncomplicating Business, to talk about high-ticket sales. Sara is a teacher-turned-business coach who helps healers, teachers and service providers build sustainable, profitable businesses without the hustle. She has a wonderful way of making the complex very, very simple.

And we had a fabulous conversation. I want to emphasize CONVERSATION, because we really went back and forth on sales, selling, marketing and the mindset goop that comes up when we raise our rates and sell our services.

So I'm sharing that conversation with you here, with a fresh intro and outro from me. Grab a notepad. There are a lot of writer-downers.

Sales is an act of service

To me, sales is an exchange of value and an exchange of service.

You're filling a need. You're providing a solution to a problem someone has. That's an act of service, and an act of love.

And when you think of sales that way, it takes the pressure off. All the stuff that feels icky (marketing yourself, building connection, building relationships) is really in service of helping someone solve a problem.

Sara put it perfectly. Sales is the thing that happens before the exchange. It's service before the service.

Helping and getting paid are NOT mutually exclusive

So many healers, teachers and creatives feel like they can't charge for their gift. Or can't charge THAT much.

Here's how I think about it. I deliver a level of my service for free in my marketing, my messaging and my pre-sale activities. Your podcast, your emails and your content can provide free or affordable transformation for people who can't (or don't want to) invest.

But the BIG transformation? That's for the people who are able to pay and work with you directly.

Sara comes from teaching, where you're basically told it should all be free. Her take: everyone is happier, including you, when the exchange of value is balanced.

We all have to make a living. We all have bills to pay. We all have kids with astronomical sports fees or theater camp fees.

There is no shame in charging a decent amount for what you deliver, so you can pay the bills, put food on the table, give back to your community and donate to the causes you love.

And women naturally give back to their communities when we have more agency to do so.

Bargain basement pricing can backfire

Sara sees a lot of clients calculate their prices down to the bare minimum. The least they can charge and still pay the bills.

Guys. We're not trying to lay on the floor.

Bargain basement pricing might be shooting yourself in the foot. People looking for an expert see the lowest rate on the block and think you can't deliver the solution they need.

The right price point tells them, "This person must be able to deliver a transformation."

Aim for the lowest common denominator and you'll sacrifice sales with the ideal clients who actually WANT to work with you.

How I started charging premium rates

I spent more than a decade in the nonprofit sector. Talk about a "there's no money" mindset.

But I was also working in major gift fundraising and grant writing, where you ask for very big gifts. So I had some practice.

When I moved into online business, I had to deal with ALL the mindset gobbledygook. I'd never worked in digital marketing. I'd never called myself a copywriter. How could I charge what other copywriters were charging?

I had to remind myself, over and over, that a decade of writing COUNTED. I wasn't called a copywriter or a messaging strategist, but that's what I'd been doing. Plus, I brought a ton of life experience. When you understand how humans think and live, you make fewer mistakes and land the plane faster.

And still, I started small:

  • $500 for my first sales page

  • Then $1,000

  • Then $1,500

  • Then $2,000

  • And so on, until people said, "Whoa, that's a lot."

I also niched down right out of the gate. I specialized in copy for high-ticket sales, for clients who were charging premium rates themselves. That meant they got a bigger ROI from my copy, and I could command higher rates. Owning that niche really worked in my favor.

Sara did something similar. Every time someone said yes, she added $300. (She had to keep a spreadsheet to track it.)

My advice: it's easier to go up than to go down. Especially with a public group offer. Start at a good value and push it as you go.

And with one-on-one work? Nobody needs a blow-by-blow of how your prices changed. They just need to know what you're charging TODAY.

The charging enables the giving

When someone really balks at the price, I keep a few strategies in my back pocket:

  • A longer payment plan (four or five payments instead of three)

  • Scholarships for people from marginalized communities or facing financial hardship

And here's the thing. I can only offer scholarships because I charge premium rates.

Sara said it best: you charge the money to enable the giving. Not the other way around.

You can be very explicit about it on your services page ("when you work with me, a third of my proceeds go back to the community"). Or you can do it quietly. Nobody has to know.

And you can change it whenever you want.

You're the boss of your own business

You get to decide what you call your offer. Whether it's open for two weeks or two days. What you charge today.

So many of us feel like everything has to be locked in cement before we move. But business is a series of tests and experiments and learning from data.

You can't know for sure and THEN act. You act, and then you'll know.

Look at what's possible (and keep a cheat sheet of awesomeness)

When I started peeking at what other copywriters charged, I thought, "Heck, if I made half that, I'd be killing it." Meanwhile, I was making about $25 an hour doing the same level of writing and strategy.

Sara pointed out that some people see that same data and feel inferior. Others see what's possible. Very different places.

What helped me get to "what's possible":

  • Mindset support. I worked with mindset coaches and joined communities with people a few steps ahead of me who'd call me out when I was playing small.

  • A pump-up song before sales calls. (Don't knock it.)

  • A cheat sheet of awesomeness. I learned this from Joanna Wiebe of Copyhackers. For a long time, I kept a list of my clients' wins on my bulletin board and read it before EVERY sales call. It reminded me that I'm actually good at what I do.

Sara does a real-time version. Before calls, she writes down her clients' names and one thing they've accomplished together. "Oh wait, we do important stuff."

And those results matter on the call too. In this "trust recession," being able to say "I helped so-and-so do this" makes dropping your price point SO much easier.

Stop giving away the free upgrade

This is an ongoing battle. Even for me.

A past client recently wanted to hire me for a series of nurture emails. Then she asked if I could turn them into LinkedIn posts too.

I wanted to say, "Sure, no problem!" It took me five or 10 minutes to talk myself out of throwing it in for free and to price it properly instead.

Spoiler alert: she didn't buy the upgrade. But I'm still delivering the emails for the same price instead of delivering more and getting paid less.

Sara admitted she does it too. A colleague recently told her, "That's too much and too nice. Make it stop."

Premium clients are easier clients

You've probably seen the meme. Pitch a $5K project to a premium client: "Great, send me the invoice." Sell a $500 service to a $500 client: "Can you tell me the terms? What exactly are my deliverables?"

It's a meme for a reason. Premium pricing brings a different level of clientele, and a different level of confidence on both sides.

And premium doesn't have to mean thousands of dollars. Sara works with a lot of people in the kids-and-families space, where going from $65 to $75 can change your people entirely.

"Dull average" is all I ever want you to be

Sara asked if I have the same money gremlins she does. Oh, of course.

My mom was a teacher. She saw what happened to the exceptional kids and the kids who struggled. So she'd tell me, "I just want you to be average. Dull average is all I ever want you to be."

She meant it from a good place. But any time I was above dull average, I'd think, "I don't deserve this."

That stuff creeps into pricing. "Don't get too big for your britches." "You've got to work hard for your money."

It's about catching yourself. It's okay to be better than dull average.

Sara's journal mantra: I am a success right now. No "except when." No "but I haven't gotten there yet."

And the data backs her up. Something like 50% of businesses close after the first year. Only about 12% of women-owned businesses ever reach $100,000. Only about 2% reach a million. Starting a business is a success. Lasting a year is a success. Lasting five is a TREMENDOUS success.

Pick a niche and talk to your 210s

If I could get everyone to make one shift, it would be picking a niche. That could be the type of service you offer, the type of person you work with, or both.

A niche lets you become THE expert. It helps you stop saying yes to everything. And it teaches you how to speak to your ideal audience in their own words.

My second wish? Speak to the ready-to-buy buyer.

I have a client in the middle of a launch who keeps telling me people are skeptical and the economy is this and the economy is that. And I keep reminding her: those aren't the people we're talking to.

We talk to the people who say, "I know I kind of want this. I'm just a little hesitant."

Sara has a friend who calls them your 210-degree people. Water boils at 212 Fahrenheit. Your 210s don't need much extra heat to boil. Your 83s? Let them do what they do.

And don't worry about leaving your beginners behind. When you paint a picture of possibility for your more sophisticated audience, your beginners get inspired by that vision too. They'll warm right up.

As Sara says, picking a place to stand doesn't mean nobody else can hear you.

Get to know Sara Torpey

Sara is a teacher-turned-business coach who helps healers, teachers and service providers build sustainable, profitable businesses without the hustle. She shares her busy household with two teen-ish kids (as she puts it) and a very large dog, and she's building a business that fits her life. Not the other way around.

Go follow her. And if you've got a takeaway from this one, I'd love to hear it.

Ready to raise YOUR rates?

If you're done pricing for the bare minimum and want messaging that sells to your ready-to-buy buyers, let's talk.

Book a call with me

Kim

Let’s Connect

Follow the Podcast

Follow Along on Instagram

Follow Along on Facebook

Connect on Linkedin

Follow & Review

Enjoy these tiny habits and quick-hit episodes? Follow or subscribe to the podcast and please leave a 5-star review!

You can do that on Apple Podcasts or Spotify! I read each of them, and they help me make sure I am providing the content you love to hear!

Plus, you get to pay it forward because it will allow other listeners like you to find the podcast!

Next
Next

180 | Business, marketing and the perimenopausal brain